---
title: "False Brinelling and Fretting Corrosion"
date: 2026-11-09
description: "If you find indentations at ball spacing on a bearing raceway, do not assume it was shock-loaded. The most common cause is vibration - false brinelling. This gu..."
source: https://en.mshjzc.com/bearing-installation-failure/58155.html
---

# False Brinelling and Fretting Corrosion

If you find indentations at ball spacing on a bearing raceway, do not assume it was shock-loaded. The most common cause is vibration - false brinelling. This guide explains how it happens and how to prevent it.

See also [bearing storage](/bearing-lubrication-maintenance/58150.html).

## What Is False Brinelling?

When a bearing is stationary but subjected to external vibration (from a running machine nearby, from shipping, from wind gusts on a turbine), the rolling elements micro-vibrate in their raceway positions. The oil film is squeezed out, metal-to-metal contact occurs, and the raceway gets indented at each rolling element position. The indentations look like true brinelling, but the bearing never actually saw a static overload.

## How to Tell It Apart

<table border="1" cellpadding="6" cellspacing="0" style="border-collapse:collapse;"><tr><th>False Brinelling</th><th>True Brinelling</th></tr><tr><td>Evenly spaced indentations at ball spacing</td><td>Random indentations, often at one side</td></tr><tr><td>Occurs when bearing is stationary</td><td>Occurs under shock load while running</td></tr><tr><td>Red or brown powder (fretting corrosion)</td><td>Bright, cold-deformed indentations</td></tr><tr><td>Common on stored or shipped equipment</td><td>Common on shock-loaded machinery</td></tr></table>

## Fretting Corrosion

The micro-motion between rolling elements and raceway also produces fine iron powder that oxidizes to a reddish-brown dust. This is fretting corrosion. It is the tell-tale sign of false brinelling. The red powder is often found packed around the bearing.

## Common Situations

- Bearings stored on a shelf near a running machine
- New machines shipped on trucks over rough roads
- Wind turbine bearings that sit idle between storms
- Pumps that are standby and vibrate from running neighbors

## Prevention

1. Do not store bearings near vibrating equipment.
2. During long storage, rotate large bearings by a quarter turn every few months.
3. For shipped machines, block the shaft to prevent micro-motion.
4. Use greases with good anti-fretting additives.
5. For standby equipment, bump-start the shaft periodically to redistribute grease.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### Can I install a bearing with false brinelling?

No. The indentations will cause noise and vibration from day one. The bearing may still run, but it will never be smooth. Replace it.

### Why does the raceway turn red?

The fine iron powder from fretting oxidizes to red rust. That red powder is the signature of false brinelling and fretting corrosion.

### Does this affect running bearings?

Running bearings do not false-brinell because the rolling elements move continuously, redistributing grease. It only happens to stationary bearings under vibration.

## Related Reading

- [Bearing Storage](/bearing-lubrication-maintenance/58150.html)
- [Fatigue Spalling](/bearing-installation-failure/58152.html)
- [Bearing Installation](/bearing-installation-failure/58151.html)

## Need Bearings for Standby Equipment?

MS Bearing supplies bearings with anti-fretting grease pre-packed for standby and outdoor applications. Send us your application, and we will recommend the correct grease and protection arrangement.
