sales@cnprv.com

+86 15862366271 (WhatsApp/WeChat)

False Brinelling and Fretting Corrosion

MS Bearing WareHouse

If you find indentations at ball spacing on a bearing raceway, do not assume it was shock-loaded. The most common cause is vibration - false brinelling. This guide explains how it happens and how to prevent it.

See also bearing storage.

What Is False Brinelling?

When a bearing is stationary but subjected to external vibration (from a running machine nearby, from shipping, from wind gusts on a turbine), the rolling elements micro-vibrate in their raceway positions. The oil film is squeezed out, metal-to-metal contact occurs, and the raceway gets indented at each rolling element position. The indentations look like true brinelling, but the bearing never actually saw a static overload.

How to Tell It Apart

False BrinellingTrue Brinelling
Evenly spaced indentations at ball spacingRandom indentations, often at one side
Occurs when bearing is stationaryOccurs under shock load while running
Red or brown powder (fretting corrosion)Bright, cold-deformed indentations
Common on stored or shipped equipmentCommon on shock-loaded machinery

Fretting Corrosion

The micro-motion between rolling elements and raceway also produces fine iron powder that oxidizes to a reddish-brown dust. This is fretting corrosion. It is the tell-tale sign of false brinelling. The red powder is often found packed around the bearing.

Common Situations

  • Bearings stored on a shelf near a running machine
  • New machines shipped on trucks over rough roads
  • Wind turbine bearings that sit idle between storms
  • Pumps that are standby and vibrate from running neighbors

Prevention

  1. Do not store bearings near vibrating equipment.
  2. During long storage, rotate large bearings by a quarter turn every few months.
  3. For shipped machines, block the shaft to prevent micro-motion.
  4. Use greases with good anti-fretting additives.
  5. For standby equipment, bump-start the shaft periodically to redistribute grease.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I install a bearing with false brinelling?

No. The indentations will cause noise and vibration from day one. The bearing may still run, but it will never be smooth. Replace it.

Why does the raceway turn red?

The fine iron powder from fretting oxidizes to red rust. That red powder is the signature of false brinelling and fretting corrosion.

Does this affect running bearings?

Running bearings do not false-brinell because the rolling elements move continuously, redistributing grease. It only happens to stationary bearings under vibration.

Related Reading

Need Bearings for Standby Equipment?

MS Bearing supplies bearings with anti-fretting grease pre-packed for standby and outdoor applications. Send us your application, and we will recommend the correct grease and protection arrangement.